Tuesday, October 16, 2012


                                Lebanon

You told me of your travels
How you had felt there, alone
The nights were dark and hot
Full of stars and melting candles
Wine and figs and conversation
Endless thoughts mingled with smoke
And your hands could not be still
You wanted to touch those minds

You told me of your travels
The sea cooled your unrest
Soothed the passion in your body
You saw colours you'd never seen
Eyes you never imagined existed
Hope, despair, and a will to continue
Underneath the wandering sun

You told me of your travels
Long days in the desert sand
Nights drowned by moonlight
Listening to those harsh voices
Sharing their endless pain
Becoming part of their conflict
Willing the wine to bring slumber

Your told me of your travels
You wanted to share your growth
And you wouldn't let me sleep
Pacing the room all night long
Throwing up your hands in wonder
Your hard legs striding, striding
Your black hair bright with perspiration

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Yael Dayan

Yael Dayan speaks at Temple Israel, Portsmouth on November 9th 2010

Yael Dayan was the first Knesset member to meet with Yasser Arafat, in 1993 in Tunis. She is the daughter of the famous IDF general, Moshe Dayan. Diminutive in stature, she more than makes up for it in personality. A lot of what she has to say is unpopular both in Israel and the United States.

She started off by pointing out to us the irony of J Street’s slogan: “Pro Israel, Pro Peace.” The fact that this is even a slogan is sad, she said, because it implies that you can also be pro Israel and against peace. And that should never be the case. Israel must always be pro peace. We should no longer be questioning its right to exist or its ability to survive, but instead we should be asking the real questions, like:

How do you manage a democracy/theocracy?

How do you manage a democracy lacking in pluralism?

How do you manage a democracy taking in immigrants from so many different cultures?

Israel should not have to choose between being a Jewish state and being a democratic state. The Zionist dream has become an occupier while we sit silently by. Israel has to be the first to show it is pro-peace – not build settlements while bilateral talks are about to start.

The Six Day War was a very meaningful event in Israel’s statehood and in our collective minds. There was a huge sense of euphoria and of victory. We thought it was the war to end all wars. This and the Yom Kippur wars were our last no-choice, defensive wars. The two Lebanon wars and the Gaza war were disasters and delayed our chance for peace. The other extremely meaningful event in Israel’s history is the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin. We must remember that his assassin was not a mad-man, but instead someone whose fanaticism had been nurtured.

The settlements were started for reasons of defense, but they are illegal. Just because you say you hear the voice of God does not make them legal.

Here in 2010 we are back at the negotiating table. And I am more interested in Israel’s rhetoric. Are we a good partner for peace? We have a foreign minister who does not want peace and a prime minister who talks peace but makes war. We have seen a regression from basic democratic values; no official should stand between you and your better judgment, between you and your sense of justice.

Yael Dayan ended by saying: We are so used to being victims; no-one can take that away from us. We say, indignantly: “They will pressure us? The only democracy in the Middle East? Survivors of the holocaust?”

Sunday, October 24, 2010

La Juderia de Malaga

Malaga - excerpt from "Toreador"

Fernando looked up and for a moment I saw anguish in his eyes. But as his eyes looked into mine their expression softened and I was happy to see a smile appear on his gorgeous face. His eyes crinkled and he shook himself a little, as if to expel some demons.

Nada, mi bonita,” he said, standing up and pulling me up with him. “Nothing, my pretty. Let’s go and have some fun.”

It was twilight when we hit the street, the sunset lending an orange-pink glow to everything. Fernando took my hand, no trace of his earlier unease visible in his demeanor. We set off at a leisurely pace, leaving the hotel Maestranza in the direction of the paseo maritimo, which ran along the waterfront of the Malagueta beach.

“There’s a great flamenco place near here,” Fernando said, strolling beside me in that fluid way of his. One of my hands was ensconced in his, but there was some distance between us.

“It’s been years since I’ve seen a flamenco performance. And even then I don’t think it was a very authentic one.” I said.

“Then you are going to enjoy this, you’ll see,” Fernando smiled.

The place Fernando took me to was tucked away in a side street and I’m sure that if you didn’t know it was there you would not have noticed its existence. The sign outside which said “La Caverna” was only dimly lit and the doorway was small and barely visible. Fernando led me inside holding on tight to my hand. And as soon as we were inside I could see why – it was obviously a popular place with the locals. We could hardly find room to stand, but somehow we made it to the bar and Fernando ordered a glass of wine for me and water for him.

As I waited for him to get our drinks I surveyed the place. It was surprisingly full for this early hour, the only free space the slightly raised, very big square stage at the back of the dark, low-ceilinged room. On both sides of the stage was a low wooden chair and behind it a dark red velvet curtain hung. Fernando appeared at my side and said:

“Looks like we’re not going to be able to sit down.”

“It looks that way,” I agreed.

“The first guitarists should be out any minute; I asked,” he said.

I sipped my wine and moved my body in a little closer to his, thinking he would put his arm around me. But instead I felt him stiffen a little and move away the tiniest bit. It reminded me of his similar reaction back at the hotel and I wondered again why he was behaving in this uncharacteristic way.

I was toying with the idea of saying something when, without any type of announcement, three men appeared from behind the curtain onto the stage. Two of them carried guitars and one a box. The three of them had thick black hair that fell in curls and waves to their shoulders and their skin was dark and pockmarked. The one with the box, a scowl of concentration on his face, set it down, sat on it and looked to the guitarists, who were making themselves comfortable on their little chairs. A hush came over the bar as the three regarded each other and then simultaneously broke into an upbeat rumba. The box turned out to be a percussion instrument, which I watched with fascination for a moment, never having seen one.

I enjoyed the music and became entranced as people started to pair up and dance. If you didn’t know how, there was really no way to move to this strident, vigorous rhythm, so I was happy to watch others. The dancers, men and women dancing in couples, expressed a controlled sensuality that was impossible not to watch. Raw emotion mixed with an animal grace that infused their bodies. I turned to look at Fernando, meaning to smile at him and show my enjoyment of the place he had brought me to, but I caught on his face an expression I had not expected to see. Preoccupation and something that looked very much like fear. I wanted to bring him back to the moment so I moved in front of him, my back to him, and pulled his arms around me to rest on my tummy. After a moment’s hesitation he squeezed me hard and buried his face in my neck, under my hair. I could feel soft his lips there and I closed my eyes to savor the sensation.

An hour must have gone by in which we were unable to speak because of the loudness of the music in the small space. We watched the dancers, listened to the musicians and then as suddenly as they had appeared, they left the stage.

Fernando kissed me with a feather-like touch of his lips and said:

“Would you like to get something to eat or watch more of this?”

I realized I was hungry so opted for the former.

Out in the street night had fallen and the air was filled with the delicious salty tang of the sea. I breathed it in and closed my eyes, holding tight to Fernando’s hand.

He smiled for the first time since we had left the hotel.

“Are you having a good time?” he asked.

“I always have a good time when I’m with you,” I answered, putting my arms around him and drawing his face down to mine. He kissed me, but I felt a certain restraint and he gently but quickly broke out of my embrace.

We strolled back along the ocean front until we reached a restaurant named Sal Gorda, which, once we were inside, I saw was entirely decorated with bullfighting paraphernalia. Fernando told me the restaurant belonged to the matador Manuel Garcia’s family. We found a table against the wall under a mounted bull’s head and almost immediately a short balding man with glasses was clapping Fernando on the back.

Hombre, I was wondering when you’d turn up!” he said cheerfully. “How have you been?”

“Manuel, let me introduce my friend Miriam,” Fernando answered, smiling as he pulled me forward.

Encantado,” Manuel Sr. said, kissing my cheeks. “Enchanted.”

“Manuel owns this wonderful restaurant,” Fran told me with a twinkle in his eye. “And tomorrow his son and I are in the same corrida.”

Manuel Sr. smiled proudly.

“As always, I am both excited and terrified,” he said with disarming honesty. He took our drinks order and Fernando looked around the restaurant, seeming distracted and a little ill at ease. He did not meet my eyes.

I was toying with the idea of telling Fernando my discovery of my grandmother’s religion but just as I had decided that I would, his cell phone rang.

As soon as he answered it his face clouded over and he got up to take the call in private, at the back of the restaurant. I watched him there, gesticulating with one arm and obviously having an argument.

He came back to the table and still without really looking at me properly said he had to go. His uncle had arrived in Malaga earlier than expected and there was something they urgently had to discuss.

“What are you going to do?” he asked me, his tone softening a little. “Would you like to stay here and have your drink or go back to the hotel?”

“I’ll stay here,” I said, making the decision to my own surprise.

In the end Fernando stayed and had his drink too, before leaving. I wasn’t entirely sure why Luis would need to talk to Fernando in person at this time of night but I didn’t press the issue and after one more drink with Manuel and his very amiable friends I set off for a solitary stroll which lead me down to the beach. I took my shoes off and enjoyed the feel of the sand between my toes, walking right down to the water’s edge. The ebb and flow of the warm sea over my toes was very soothing and I felt myself relax a little. So the evening hadn’t gone quite as planned. But still here I was, in Malaga with Fernando. After a while I sat down in the sand and regarded the silver path the moon etched on the sea. Other people passed me on the sand: young couples, couples with children, and a few solitary strollers like me.

I sat there for a while, not wanting to hurry back to the hotel to sit in the room by myself for hours. But eventually I did get up and started back, taking Arenal St. As I was nearing the corner with Reding St., where the hotel was, I was surprised to find someone falling in step beside me. I looked up quickly, feeling panic rise in me when I didn’t recognize who it was straight away. But then the man beside me turned to me and I saw that it was Fernando’s uncle, Luis.

“Oh, hello,” I said, surprised and relieved. “I thought you and Fernando were together.”

“We finished,” Luis answered shortly. “I wanted a word with you as well.”

“You did?” I was even more surprised.

“I wanted to tell you that it would be in your own best interests not see Fernando anymore after you get back to Ronda,” he said clearly and without emotion.

I stopped in my tracks and looked at him.

“Now why on earth would you say that to me?”

Luis ignored my question and went on in the same manner as before.

“Don’t say anything to him tonight – you don’t want to upset him in any way before a corrida.”

I remained rooted to the spot. I was being told by Fernando’s close family member and mentor to stay away from him but to pretend, for now, that nothing was going on? My head reeled and I had a sudden strong urge to get away from this man, his bulk seeming suddenly menacing beside me.

“Good night,” I said and took off as fast as my shoes allowed me to.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

White City of Tel Aviv

CAMERA presentation at Temple Israel, Porstmouth

I had been looking forward to the CAMERA (Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America) presentation to be held at our temple on October 17th. I guess I should have known better. The first speaker was Ari Alexenberg of the Israel Action Center of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Boston. A Temple member and knowledgeable and affable man, he started off by quoting Jose Maria Aznar:

“Israel is a fundamental part of the West. The West is what it is thanks to its Judeo-Christian roots. If the Jewish element of those roots is upturned and Israel is lost, then we are lost too. Whether we like it or not, our fate is inextricably intertwined.” (The Times, June 17, 2010)

This is not the exact same quote that he used, but they were words to that effect, also spoken by Aznar. I was pleased and surprised that anyone in this country would start off their speech by quoting a Spaniard. Spain is almost completely ignored in the US, for reasons I have still to figure out.

Alexenberg went on to explain that the 2001 conference on racism in Durban, South Africa, was the start of the “soft war” against Israel. It was a conference that rapidly turned into a hate-fest directed at Israel, where it was accused of genocide, of being an apartheid state and of crimes against humanity. And this was all before the current coalition government, which includes Yisrael Beteinu and Shas, came into power . It’s all in the choice of words, Alexenberg told us. The campaign to delegitimize Israel is stronger in the European Union, where Arabs, post-Zionist Jews and the political left wing are busy using a strategy that blurs the lines between legitimate criticism of Israel and outright attacks on Israel, questioning its right to exist.

Next Alexenberg mentioned Natan Sharansky’s 3 “D”s: Double-standards, Delegitimizing and Demonizing. The campaign to delegitimize Israel seriously limits its right to defend itself. Whenever it takes any action it has to be on the defensive right from the start.

The next speaker was Steven Stotsky, a senior research analyst with CAMERA and a man singularly lacking in charisma. After some technical difficulties with his laptop he presented us with a slideshow in which he highlighted the following, to name but a few.

On October 13th 2010 the Netanyahu government offered a freeze on all settlement building in return for recognition (by the Palestinians) of Israel as a Jewish state. The Palestinians’ answer was no.

The Arab countries around Israel occupy 5,000,000m2. Israel occupies 10,000m2. Stotsky told us that this fact is worth keeping in mind when “land for peace” is being discussed.

In 1967 the UN passed resolution 242 which calls Gaza and the West Bank “disputed” rather than “occupied” territories.

Anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism. It is denying the Jewish people a state of their own.

The UN Human Rights Council has passed more resolutions condemning Israel than all the other 191 countries combined. Apparently there is a standing item on the agenda that is Israel’s human rights violations.

The following Jews were named for their extreme views and strong efforts to delegitimize Israel: Richard Falk, Ilan Pappe, Neve Gordon and Norman Finkelstein.

Organizations to be avoided as anti-Semitic are: Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, Jewish Voice for Peace, International Solidarity Movement and Jews for Justice for Palestinians.

When Jeff Goldberg (I have always enjoyed his advice column in The Atlantic) was mentioned, his name was followed by “not a great friend to Israel.” I was surprised, although at this point maybe I shouldn’t have been. After all, Goldberg, for one, has come down hard on J Street after it is becoming less and less clear if they are really pro-Israel. And speaking of which, the last person Stotsky mentioned was Daniel Levy of J Street, who allegedly said that the founding of Israel was wrong.

The next speaker was Jerry White. I didn’t take a single note of his presentation because as soon as he started to talk I knew I wasn’t going to like what he had to say. Although I did not realize to what extent that would turn out to be true. He had a loud, strident manner of speaking and although he seemed amusing (if grating) at first, it soon became clear that he was arrogant and pompous. He told us that we have an insidious enemy in our midst, and that enemy is every liberal progressive “Jew” (his speech marks). He urged us to listen to Conservative talk radio and befriend Evangelical Christians (all of whom want us to return to Israel to bring about their Messiah's Second Coming, not because they care in the least about us). Then he told us to stay away from the New York Times and PBS and ended by calling left wing Jews “vermin.”

Now the funny thing is that I knew that his name was White and that he was originally from Canada, but it took going to his break out session to confront him for the penny to drop. And even then it took a while. He was sitting in the library with a small group of people, amongst them a familiar face.

“Lily!” I exclaimed. “How are you?”

“Oh hello” she answered. “Have you spoken to Karen lately?”

“Not very recently,” I answered.

“She’s pregnant.”

“Mazal tov!” I said, as inside it was beginning to dawn on me: this man who I had come to argue with was my good friend’s father-in-law. Oh well, I thought. I am not one to be shut up that easily.

I opened by saying: “You said that you’d be happy if people were angry with you when you had finished speaking. Well, be happy. I’m angry.”

He seemed more taken aback than anything else.

“Are you telling me that I cannot be a liberal progressive and a Jew?” I went on.

“No, you cannot,” he answered coolly. “You will have to relearn your Jewish values.”

“And who gave you the authority to decide who is a Jew?” I asked.

Someone else piped up at this moment and backed me up.

Before I had had enough of listening to his loud and deeply narrow-minded views, I asked him if he thought that Avigdor Lieberman might have something to do with Israel’s current unpopularity.

“Avigdor Lieberman is a great man,” He answered.

Lehitra’ot, Jerry.